Solution for the middle regions of Somalia

[Xaaji Xunjuf]

When it comes to forming federal states its better to divided galguduud into two regions than they will fulfill the criteria of forming a federal state the same with hiiraan , hiiraan needs to be divided to into 2 regions if that happened than reer hiiraan can have their federal state to. The Parliament just needs to approve more regions only for those 2 regions. Since the rest of the country is pretty much fine with its regions.

[xiinfaniin]

You would be better thinking how federalism would apply to Somaliland, than wasting your ink on areas that does not concern you , mr xunduf

[Somalia]

By this logic, everyone can double their regions, is this a race or something, Puntland would have 3 states then :eek: Xaaji are you suggesting special rules for some, in 2013, when we are moving forward, ceeb caleyk :eek:

[Xaaji Xunjuf]

Xiinfanin what ever happens in Somalia concerns me,federalism and Somaliland is an oxymoron no one in Somaliland calls for federalism in Somaliland we have a centralized goverment in hargeisa and every one is happy.

[Xaaji Xunjuf]

Somalia;926974 wrote:

By this logic, everyone can double their regions, is this a race or something, Puntland would have 3 states then :eek: Xaaji are you suggesting special rules for some, in 2013, when we are moving forward, ceeb caleyk :eek:

Than it will be basically impossible to create a federal state in galguduud and mudug where the HAG sub clans dominate since they cannot share a state it needs to be divided. Somalia not every one is like Puntland. They cannot unite under one federal state so why not create two more regions. why would that hurt you. Dont you want federalism?

[Somalia]

Well, it's mixed, sometimes I cry and sometimes I laugh, the reason being HAG don't want federalism because they claim it will divide Somalis yet they can't even unite at the regional level so why should I unite with them kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk

 

I think regions such as these should be provinces if they don't want federalism it shouldn't be forced on them.

[Xaaji Xunjuf]

^^ But that it self will be a mess that contradicts that Somalia is a federal republic if Southern Mudug galguduud hiiraan those 3 region will be directly administrated by xamar including xamar its self banadir 4 regions. How does that work you cannot have 2 systems in one country. It will be chaos.The problem is HAG cannot share a state because they are not clan orientated they are regional people for instance every HAG will claim to be from xamar while some are from galguduud or middle shabelle. For the Puntlanders its different they had the Maguartania sultanate they just re named it Puntland they identify them selves first with their clan than the regions for HAG its different. The Jubbalanders have the same problem have never shared a state together well under British east Africa but even back than they never agreed also lots of change demographically the past 100 years there.