Who Discovered the Metrical Structure of Somali Poetry: Arale or Gaarriye? by Dr. Sai

[NASSIR]

Very interesting and detailed perspective on the Arale-Garriye debate about who contributed more to the metrical structure and codification of Somali Literature.

 

Who Discovered the Metrical Structure of Somali Poetry: Arale or Gaarriye? by Dr. Said Fahia

[Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar]

Labadoodaba waxaa dhaama Careys Ciise Kaarshe.

 

Sababtaa u leeyahay waxee tahay, waa mida koowaad, haddaa dhageysatid saararkiisa ereyo Afsoomaaliga u wada dhameystiran, nooc walba inta lahjadadood ee Afsoomaaliga ka buuxaan, oo Afsoomaali qof dhameeye barashadiisa iyo garashadiisa u ekaa.

 

Mida labaad waa suu ugu dhawaaqaayo saararkiisa soo jiidashada leh, qofka ku qasbeyso in uu dhageysto.

[Jacaylbaro]

Awoowe halka laga hadlayaa Areys Ciise (AUN) way ka sarraysaa ...............

[Abwaan]

lol...MMA & JB kulligood waxaa dhaama... check this

[Hunguri]

Somalidu waxay ku maahmaahdaa. War la helyaaba talo la hel. Oodweyne, niyo anigu qoraaladaada ma wada akhriyi karo, waayo aad iyo aad ayay u badanyihiin. Laakiin, waxaan kuu sheegayaa. Dr Carraale iyo Gaariye sheekadoodu inay aad u dheertahay. Tusaale ahaan, markii lagu dhex dhexaadiyey (Norway/Oslo) nimankii garta naqqay, waxay garta siiyeen Gaariye. Hase ahaatee, may ahayn ilaa iyo xad niman u war haya mawduucan ( Yaa daah furay miisaanka maansada Somaliyeed).

 

Dr.Carraale, maaha nin caan ku ah Somalida dhexdeeda. Waayo, waa nin xag aqqooneed aad u dhisan, xogta iyo caddaynta sheegaysa inuu Dr Carraale miisaanka maansada leeyahayna, waxaa ka mid ah:

 

(1) Waraysi laga qaaday inantii Fadumo-Cureji oo ahayd shaqaalihii Somali National University, markii danbena noqotay Vice Minister of education, ayaa waxay haysaa kaydkii iyo Hantidii Jaamacada, waxayna haysaa buugii Carraale 1976 qoray, kagana sheekaynayo Miisaanka Maansada

 

(2) Waxaa jira, rag fara badan oo Gaariye markhaati ka dhigtay, Hadraawi iyo Rashiid Sheekh Cabdillaahina ka mid yihiin, hase ahaatee Gaariye wax marag ah may siin

 

(3) Dr Arrale, wuxuu hayaa wax taffa tiran, qaab xisaabeed iyo qaab cilmina dhisan. Muujinaya, inuu yahay ninkii fakradan iska lahaa, Jaamacadii ummada Somaliyeed ay ansixisay, dhinac kastana isu dheelli tiran.

 

(4)Gaariye, waa suugaanyahan Somaliyeed. Cidina uma diidana, laakiin maaha nin wuxuu ku doodayo, qaab cilmiyan ah uga doodi kara. Waxa uu hayaana, ma dhaafsiisna hadal iyo Joornaalkii Xidigta Waaberi caddad ka mid ahaa, oo soo baxay 1978. Soona qoray inuu Gaariye yahay ninkii daah furay miisaanka maansada. Caddaynta Dr Carraale hayaa, way ka wayntahay tan Gaariye. Waxaana saaran ansixin ay ansixisay NSU.

 

Almuhim, Oodweyne aan kula kaftamee, Dr Arrale waa nin reer Oodweyne ah. Maaha reer Dhahareed. markaa hadaad qoraalka Dhahar ku aragtay, waxba dhiiga haysku karine. Bal wax soo dhaga dhageey....

 

Nabady

[Maaddeey]

General-ka ama Poetry section-ka sow kuma fiicnayn?

[Abtigiis]

Maaddeey,

 

Ma tan siyaasad ka weyn baad aragtay? laba reerood baa isku haysta arinkan. It is beyond the two persons involved.

[Maaddeey]

^^

[Koora-Tuunshe]

Waxa ay Gaariye iyo Caraale ku doodayaan waa uun yaa hor qoray. Laakiin araahda iyo sharciyada suugaanta iyo abla ablaynta afSoomaaliga labadaba wey ka horeysey, ee waxaa horey u sharaxay Allaha u naxariistee Raage Ugaas, iyaguna taa madiidin wali:-

 

Waxaana tusaale u ah markuu Raage Ugaas leeyahay:

 

"Hadal waa tiraab iyo tix uun, waxaad tidhaahdaaye."

[Koora-Tuunshe]

Originally posted by Jacaylbaro:

Awoowe halka laga hadlayaa Areys Ciise (AUN) way ka sarraysaa ...............

Soomaali dhibka heystaa wuxuu yahay, kan ayaa sareeya iyo kan waalaga sareeyaa! MMA fikir ahaan waan la qabaa in labadaba Suugaan ahaan uu Careys uu soo jiidasho leeyahay.

[Som@li]

Interesting read, why is it in Political section?

[Miskiin-Macruuf-Aqiyaar]

Originally posted by Koora-Tuunshe:

quote:Originally posted by Jacaylbaro:

Awoowe halka laga hadlayaa Areys Ciise (AUN) way ka sarraysaa ...............

Soomaali dhibka heystaa wuxuu yahay, kan ayaa sareeya iyo kan waalaga sareeyaa! MMA fikir ahaan waan la qabaa in labadaba Suugaan ahaan uu Careys uu soo jiidasho leeyahay.

U sheeg. Sareeyaa kulahaa. Aniga Careys ayaa sareeyo ma dhihin. Aragtideyda dhiibtay oo ah in uu asaga, waa Careys Ciise Kaarshe, ila soo jiidasho leeyahay than the other two, not that I have anything against the other two.