PM: the execution will go ahead as planned

[Libaax-Sankataabte]

Singapore PM OKs drug smuggler's hanging

Young Australian to be executed Friday despite pleas from his government

MSNBC News Services

Updated: 8:28 a.m. ET Dec. 1, 2005

 

BERLIN - Singapore's Prime Minister Lee Hsien Loong said Thursday the execution of a convicted Australian drug smuggler will go ahead as planned at dawn on Friday.

 

"We have stated our position clearly," Lee said in answer to a question after meeting with German Chancellor Angela Merkel. "The penalty is death."

 

Australia been lobbying for months to stop the execution of 25-year-old heroin trafficker Nguyen Tuong Van, who received a mandatory death sentence after he was caught in 2002 at Singapore's Changi Airport on his way home to Melbourne carrying nearly 14 ounces of heroin.

 

Earlier Thursday, Australian Attorney General Philip Ruddock called it "a most unfortunate, barbaric act that is occurring."

 

Ruddock criticized the imposition of the death penalty, especially in Nguyen’s case which he said had mitigating circumstances -- Nguyen said he smuggled the drugs to try and pay off loan-shark debt for his brother in Australia.

 

Asked about the comment, Lee would only say that "the Australian press is colorful."

 

Lee emphasized that all factors, including Australian letters for clemency, had been "taken into account" but said that "the law will have to take its course."

 

He said had the drugs gotten into circulation they would have caused misery for thousands of people, and said his country had to uphold the rule of law "with impartiality for Singaporeans and foreigners alike."

 

Strong allies

Singapore is one of Australia’s strongest allies in Asia and Australian Prime Minister John Howard has rejected calls for trade and military boycotts over the execution, which is scheduled for Friday.

 

Howard has, however, made five personal pleas to Singapore and his foreign and justice ministers have also called for clemency. But the city-state has stood firm, saying it would not allow Singapore to be used as a transit for illicit drugs.

 

Nguyen’s lawyer, Lex Lasry, told Australian television from Singapore that Nguyen, a Catholic whose family came from Vietnam, was “ready to dieâ€.

 

“He has little concern for himself. He has a great insight into his situation and he is, in fact, ready to die,†he said.

 

Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer confirmed Nguyen’s mother Kim Nguyen would be allowed to hold hands with her son before his execution.

 

But Singapore had knocked back a request that Nguyen and his mother be allowed to hug one last time.

 

“It’ll perhaps be very meager compensation, of course it will be, but it will be nice that they can touch each other,†Downer told reporters in Canberra.

 

'Playing God'

While many Australians are holding candle-lit vigils for Nguyen on the eve of his execution, the country is divided.

 

A survey by Morgan Poll conducted on Wednesday night showed 47 percent of Australians believe Nguyen should be executed, 46 percent said the death penalty should not be carried out, and seven percent were undecided.

 

Singapore has not published polls on the death penalty, but many people say they are in favor of it.

 

“We must have the death penalty in Singapore. If we do not take strict measures, many more drug smugglers will come to Singapore and destroy the country,†said P. Subramaniam, a 56-year-old shop owner, as he sold chilies to a customer.

 

Tengku Sri Melati felt otherwise.

 

“Having the death penalty is like playing God. We have no right to take lives away from another human being. Punish the criminal but don’t kill him,†said the 23-year-old Muslim woman who is a researcher at a business institution.

 

Some 420 people have been hanged in Singapore since 1991, mostly for drug trafficking, an Amnesty International 2004 report said. That gives the country of 4.4 million people the highest execution rate in the world relative to population.

 

Nguyen’s hanging is set for the same day the United States is due to execute its 1,000th prisoner since 1977.

 

Australia abolished the death penalty decades ago. The last man hanged in Australia was convicted murderer Ronald Ryan who was hanged in a Melbourne prison in 1967.

 

© 2005 MSNBC Interactive

[Baluug]

I don't know why the Australian gov't and the public are so outraged by this. Singapore is internationally known, and has been for years, for their strict corporal and capital punishment for offences that would not even warrant jail time in other countries. I have no sympathy for this Nguyen guy because he obviously knew the law, or if he didn't, that's still his fault. It's like they say, "When in Rome, do as the Romans do".

[Janna]

Nguyen Tuong Van death has final arrived. I woke up this morning as Nguyen Tuong Van's execution has already happened. They should be more coverage throughout the day telling of Nguyen's death. Reading the papers and watching the news surely isn't enough.

 

It's sad to see a young man's life end so soon. However Singapore has the right to keep their country clean and pure. If Nguyen's execution had no gone ahead surely they would have been a up roar among the people in Singapore since a father was recently executed over drugs.